📐The Hidden Math of Free Shipping

👋 Hi all, Kent here.

If you’re selling online, you need to ship your orders to your customers. The problem is, no one wants to pay for it.

Amazon Prime has trained shoppers to expect fast, free shipping. But here's the thing - it's never actually "free." Unfortunately, as e-commerce has grown, the cost of parcel shipping has only gone up.

The good news? You can turn shipping from a cost center into a profit driver. We did it last year at my company, boosting our AOV by $22 with one carefully calculated change. 

Today I'll show you exactly how we did it as well as the tactics and tools you can use to turn the shipping problem into a conversion solution. 

This week:

💰 The real cost of cart abandonment (hint: it’s way more than you think)

🧮 How to calculate your perfect free shipping threshold

🎯 Next-level tactics to turn shipping into a profit driver

THE PROBLEM

Before we dive into solutions, let's look at why this matters:

• 48% of online shoppers abandon their carts due to extra costs like shipping

• 41% of global shoppers cite high delivery fees specifically as their reason for abandonment

• 24% abandon due to slow delivery options

• The total cost of abandoned carts? A staggering $4 trillion per year 🤯

This means shipping isn't just an operational concern - it's potentially your biggest conversion killer.

LET’S TALK UNIT ECONOMICS

In February last year, my company's average order value from Meta-attributed sales was just under $150 each month. 

BTW - I know this because I track monthly meta spend, sales, clicks, AOV, and net revenue (sales less spend). I highly recommend doing this, because it makes it easier to track your progress and trends over time.

In March our AOV jumped to $172 (+15%).

The difference? One simple change - we implemented a free shipping threshold of $150. But the story of how we landed on that number is more interesting - and useful - than you might think.

Our products are heavy - they’re made from recycled tires, average about 30 pounds per pack. Even our smaller packages clock in at weights that make shipping companies salivate. For our lower-priced SKUs ($110-130 range), our flat "free shipping" offer was taking a massive bite out of our profit margins (think $20 on average, but up to $30+ at times). 

On the other hand our larger SKUs (north of $300) have enough room to absorb free shipping costs. So we could easily afford it on the higher ticket items (where a big shipping charge is even more likely to kill a sale.) 

This created an interesting puzzle: how do you implement a free shipping threshold that works for both scenarios?

How We Picked Our Number

We landed on $150 as our threshold. 

Here's exactly why:

• Our site-wide AOV was hovering around $147. This was the number we wanted to improve, but we also needed to set the threshold within reach for those spending $110-$130 for our lower priced products. 

• Our best-selling SKU sells at $149.95. Getting buyers to add just one small item to hit free shipping on this item could mean thousands in additional revenue over the year due to volume.

• If we set the threshold at $200, we knew that would be way too big a stretch for our smaller pack buyers. No one is going to spend an extra $80 to save $20.  

But these were secondary considerations. The real work started with the unit economics.

The Actual Math You Need to Do

First, you need your true margin. Not the “revenue - cost of goods sold” one. Your contribution margin that prices in all of your costs:

1. Start with gross margin (after COGS and packaging)

2. Subtract marketplace fees

3. Account for returns/refunds

4. Add in pick & pack and warehousing costs

5. Take off freight costs

6. Consider what you plan to use as a discount for sales

And then remember that you’ll have a cost of acquisition on top of all of everything else. 

Do this for every SKU. 

Now for the fun part - your actual shipping costs.

If you're working with zone-based shipping (most of us are), you need a weighted average shipping cost for each SKU. 

Here's how:

1. Get your sales data by state

2. Map each state to its shipping zone (Example: if you're in Florida, California is zone 8)

3. Calculate what percentage of sales come from each zone

4. Get shipping quotes for each SKU to each zone

5. Weight the costs by your sales distribution

Here’s a raw Google Sheets example I put together for you for how to quickly calculate weighted average. 

Notice the formula at the top.

Again, do this across your catalog. 

Put all that data together. SKU PRICE - (COGS + COSTS + SHIPPING) = contribution margin. Look at the ratio and your raw net dollars left after everything.

NEXT LEVEL TACTICS

Once you have your baseline numbers dialed in, here are some tactics to maximize your shipping strategy:

🏷️ Hide it in the price

• If your “base price” is $50 and shipping averages $12, set your price at $62+ and offer "free shipping"

  • This can improve conversion rates significantly because it removes that added fee during checkout

  • BUT it removes the lever of getting people to add more to their cart

  • It also eliminates free shipping as an offer in abandoned carts or during sales

🚨Competitive analysis

• Understanding how your competitors handle shipping incentives can help

  • It gives you an idea of where to put your threshold

  • You’ll want to know where the market it is to stay competitive  

🎮 Gamify the experience 

• Add progress bars showing how close customers are to free shipping

• Consider celebration animations when they hit the threshold

• Some stores even add countdowns to create urgency

🛍️ Smart upsell placement

• Show recommended products in cart or during the checkout flow

• Keep suggestions relevant to what's already in the cart

• Make upsells “one-click” so they are as low friction as possible

📊 Test everything

• Watch both AOV and conversion rate - they can move inversely

• Test different messaging around your threshold

• Try different upsell and cross sell sequences, depending on the depth and breadth of your catalo

📦 Layer your shipping options

• Offer the cheapest shipping free above threshold

• Add premium options like 2-day shipping or priority order processing

Using free shipping as an anchor makes paying for speed feel like a choice. This lets motivated buyers self-select into paid shipping. 

TOOLS & RESOURCES

Here are some key tools to help implement your shipping and checkout optimization strategy:

Shipping Calculators: Pirate Ship 

• Free USPS zone map tool

• Compare shipping rates across carriers

• No subscription required

• Perfect for small-medium businesses calculating zone-based costs

Competitor & Market Analysis: SEMrush Competitor Website Analysis Tools & SEMrush Market Explorer Tools

• Uncover everything about your competitors

• Discover their pricing, marketing, and social tactics

• Get an clear overview of your region, market and category

Checkout Optimization: Pretty Damn Quick 

• A/B test different shipping thresholds

• Personalize checkout experiences

• Recently raised $25M in Series A funding

• Built specifically for Shopify stores

Cart Optimization: Aftersell

• Sales motivator bar

• Smart product recommendations

• Test different upsell sequences

• Optimize for shipping thresholds

• Shows relevant add-ons based on cart contents

THE TAKEAWAY

Your customers want free shipping, and they don’t really care what it costs you. 

So you need to get strategic. Flat free shipping can put you out of business while charging shipping on everything can kill your conversion rates. 

First, get your mind around your unit economics. Then you can explore the psychological levers that turn shipping from a necessary evil into a revenue and conversion driver.

With ❤️,

Kent Wilson

At The Early Checkout, we are strongly committed to protecting your privacy and providing a safe & high-quality online experience for all visitors. See our Terms & Conditions here. If you have any questions, reply to this email or visit our Website to view our official policies.